Yuki Tsunoda (file photo, 2025 season). Photo: Liauzu, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Nobody hit anybody. Nobody left the track. The controversy sitting on Audi Revolut F1 Team’s desk this week isn’t a stewards’ inquiry into dangerous driving — it’s a dispute over who gets blamed for an extra lap.
At the start of the Italian Grand Prix, Race Control ordered a second formation lap before the field could get going, a call tied to where Yuki Tsunoda’s Racing Bulls car was positioned on its approach to the grid. Tsunoda wasn’t accused of a false start; his front tyres never crossed the grid box lines. But under Article B5.9.4 of the FIA’s Formula 1 Sporting Regulations, a driver judged responsible for triggering an extra formation lap is required to peel off into the pit lane and start the race from there. Fail to do that, and the penalty is automatic: a stop-and-go.
Tsunoda never went to the pit lane. He started from his grid slot, drove a clean race, and crossed the line tenth — the last point-scoring position on offer at Monza. Nobody told him beforehand that Race Control considered him the cause of the second lap, so he had no reason to think the pit lane requirement applied to him at all.
That’s the argument the stewards accepted in their ruling, and it’s worth sitting with, because it isn’t really about what Tsunoda did on track — it’s about what he was told. The panel found the extra lap came from the Race Director’s own assessment rather than any clear infringement his team could be shown, and that neither the driver nor Visa Cash App Racing Bulls received a message flagging him as the cause. Without that notice, the stewards reasoned, there was no fair way to punish him for skipping a pit lane start he was never warned he needed to make. They even suggested the FIA build a formal process for telling teams when they’re being blamed for a restart — a tidy admission that the current system left a hole big enough for a driver to drive straight through it, point intact.
Which is why Audi cares. Gabriel Bortoleto crossed the line eleventh, seven seconds behind Tsunoda. Nico Hulkenberg followed in twelfth. Had the stewards gone the other way and hit Tsunoda with the stop-and-go, Bortoleto inherits tenth and the point that comes with it. That’s the entire dispute in one sentence: Audi isn’t appealing a block or a near-miss, it’s appealing a decision that determined, by seconds, who kept a single championship point.
One point sounds trivial until you look at where Audi actually sits. After Monza, the constructors’ table has Haas seventh on 21 points, Audi eighth on 16, and Williams ninth on 11 — a three-team scrap covering ten points total, in only Audi’s first season fielding a full factory Formula 1 effort since taking over what used to be Sauber. That gap decides prize-money tiers among midfield teams with no room to write off small mistakes, which is exactly the arithmetic Williams has been running all year while it locks in its own long-term plans around a tight cost cap.
Getting that point back runs through Article 15 of the FIA’s International Sporting Code and the Judicial and Disciplinary Rules, and it’s a narrower road than fans tend to assume. A right of review isn’t a do-over for a ruling a team simply dislikes; the applicant has to produce a significant, relevant new element that was unavailable to the stewards, and to Audi, when the decision was made. Arguing the stewards misread the rulebook doesn’t clear that bar by itself. What might: radio traffic, timing data, or a Race Control log showing Tsunoda’s team actually was told, contradicting the stewards’ central finding that no such message went out. Absent something like that, this stays exactly what it looks like on paper — a team formally logging its objection to a paperwork gap in an obscure procedural rule, over one point, in a fight where every point counts.
It wasn’t the only moment at Monza where the stewards gave a Racing Bulls-adjacent driver the benefit of the doubt over an Audi car. Liam Lawson picked up nothing more than a black-and-white flag for squeezing Hulkenberg wide at Turn 4, in what was his second stint back in a Red Bull seat this year. Neither incident alone is scandalous. Together, they’re the kind of weekend that makes a small team start counting.
The next data point arrives fast. Formula 1 is already at Madrid for the series’ debut on the new Madring layout, a circuit and rulebook nobody in the paddock has raced under before. Whatever the FIA’s International Court of Appeal eventually decides about the Tsunoda ruling, Audi doesn’t get to wait for it — Hulkenberg and Bortoleto are back on track this weekend, chasing the same handful of points the earlier decision cost them.
About the Author
